Friday, August 11, 2017

More tales of the ByzanPict Empire – Saved by surprise gavelkind!





OK, so it looks like I might have saved the empire after all, but in doing so I made a couple of sacrifices and created a couple of other problems I’m going to have to deal with further down the line.

So I finished trouncing the Serbia/Croatia revolt and revoking those two titles while beating down the Avarian duke and his claimant to a white peace. I also dealt with an annoying adventurer, but since banishing him and confiscating his 500 gold (along with a 350 gold loan from Jewish merchants and a couple of ransoms) is all that is keeping me solvent right now.

That done, I was able to deal with the succession issue. Domelch, despite waiting patiently in the wings for all of Uirup’s long reign, was going to be very disappointed. I switched my primary title to the Byzantine Empire and destroyed the Empire of Pictland title, effectively merging the two empires into one giant, purple blob, all of which would go to Amalrich “the Just” of Hamburg. I admit that was a hard call to make. I’ve placed a lot of care into maintaining the Pictish identity of my empire, even foregoing turning Scottish and getting decent retinues. And now after scuffling to turn parts of Italy and North Africa from purple to blue now I’ve turned them purple again. It kind of hurts to look upon it. I have to keep reminding myself that my Empire has not been defeated, merely morphed into something else.

Domelch then died of an infected wound, meaning that this action could actually have turned out to be pointless.

Uirup “The Holy” finally died, aged 78 years old, having been, on the face of it one of the most successful rulers I’ve ever had. But I will admit I was not sad to see the back of the incompetent A-hole. A man literally nobody liked, he still managed to join the two largest empires in the world. However, he couldn’t resist one last fuck up on the way out the door. In destroying the Empire of Pictland, he ensured both empires would go to one man. Unfortunately, that man was a German. Germans can’t use Tanistry succession because they’re not from the right culture group. That means that the Empire has gone back to default succession settings. And that means…

Gavelkind.

FUCKING GAVELKIND.

Before I realised what was happening, I had lost everything. Uirup’s death caused all of my kingdoms split between his sons, creating the two single most powerful vassals I have ever had, whilst simultaneously reducing my demesne to one single county (Constantinople, but still). The stress of dealing with all this while secretly practicing Islam killed poor Amalrich immediately, the Empire and Constantinople passing to his son, Kaiser Amalrich II, the third ruler in under five years. So, to more clearly explain what is happening, I lost a number of the titles that were on tanistry due to elections, and the ones that defaulted to gavelkind were split among my heirs in a grotesque clusterfuck that left me virtually landless.

Despite this, I’m down to a more manageable five vassals over my limit, I’m back up to 63 gold a month coming in, and my troop levies are finally getting back to normal, currently sitting at around 60,000 men. So… the empire is stable now.

What is NOT stable, is Amalrich II’s position at the top of it. And oh my god, you thought Uirup was an incompetent. This guy is… not good. No stats above five. Total schlub. On top of that, he’s gay, and so’s his wife, so getting an heir is going to be a problem. For now, his vassals seem to like him and there is minimal plotting against him, even with the council not over their new-monarch jitters. Cenræd “The Son of Satan”, Uirup’s Anglo-Saxon child by the disfigured Duchess, now reigns as King of Sicily, Wallachia, Croatia and Serbia, while his genius half-brother Enudaig reins as King of Scotland (*sob* he changed it to Scotland), Mauretania, Andalusia, and Ireland. I also have four king titles, but each is only titular i.e. has no actual lands attached to it.

So, aims going forward:
1)      Neutralise Cenræd and Enudaig
2)      Enlarge demesne
3)      Conquer remaining provinces needed to create Roman Empire
4)      Change succession to anything except gavelkind

The first one should be tricky. How to do this? Assassins are out of the question due to Amalrich’s lamentable intrigue stats, so I suppose I shall have to trick one of them into rebelling and use the other’s forces to crush them. Then I revoke their titles, take their armies and use them to wipe the floor with the other one. I may concentrate my efforts of Enudaig, since he is the more pertinent threat than his rather dull-minded brother. Sadly, Enudaig had a claim on Francia I was going to use, dating from when he was back-up heir to Domelch but I think giving him MORE power would be a very poor idea at this point.

Point two: I am inundated with options in this regard due to my new position in East giving me a wad of holy war options. I think my first move will be to grab Baghdad and its surrounding counties from the Sheikdom that owns it. If I get there quickly with a lot of men I should be able to get them without any bother. The other option is to take Famagusta on Cyprus from the Georgian Revolt. Other possible easy targets include Antioch, which is an independent duchy.

Which leads us on to point three: I need Antioch, Jerusalem and one more county in Italy to reform the Roman Empire. Antioch won’t be a problem, and neither will the county in Italy (probably a vassal will take care of that before long). Jerusalem, on the other hand, belongs to France, and I would like to avoid fighting them if at all possible. Spoiler alert: It won’t be. Eventually I’m going to have to fight them, probably a few times to get Jerusalem away from them.

And on the succession issue: I can’t use tanistry anymore since I’m no longer in the Celtic culture group, so I’m going to switch to primo as soon as Amalrich’s ruled for 10 years.That means I'm stuck as a German for now. Going to try and get a Pict to educate my heirs.

All right. Let’s try this out. Death to Enudaig and Cenræd! SPQR!

Saturday, July 29, 2017

The Zenith of the Pictish Empire - More Crusade Kings 2 stories






I have broken Crusader Kings 2. I have actually destroyed my game. It’s fucked.

As the Emperor of a sprawling, pan-European Pictish hegemony, I’ve finally reached the tipping point. You know how when people show you maps of the Roman Empire, it’s almost always during the reign of Emperor Trajan, when the empire was at its greatest extent? Well, I’ve reached that point now, and I’m having a hard time admitting to myself that I may have reached the pinnacle of my achievement, and the only thing I have to look forward to a slow descent into chaos, civil war and fiscal oblivion. Even though I’m only in the 1320s and have around 100 years of game-time left, I have to admit I’m a little reluctant to switch on for my nightly 30-min gaming session, because it pains me too much to see the great realm I’ve built over the better part of 7 months fall apart. YES I KNOW I SAID IN MY EARLIER POST I’D BEEN PLAYING FOR ‘A COUPLE OF MONTHS’ BUT WHAT I REALLY MEANT WAS MORE THAN HALF A YEAR. SUE ME.

*sigh* How did I get into this situation?

House Uerterio start out in 769 as the puny earls of Fortriu in the Highlands of Scotland. I picked Fortriu because I wanted to play as the descendants of Bridei of Fortriu, the Pictish king who humbled the Northumbrians at the battle of Dun Nechtain in 685. My early aims were as follows:

1)      Usurp the Kingdom of Pictland
2)      Form culturally Pictish Empire of Brittania

As we will see I was successful in step 1, but the Saxon kingdoms in the south proved a harder nut to crack. I would have them eventually, but by that time my holdings were too diverse to make something like de-Saxonifying England make much sense.

This was my first time playing as a vassal, and also my first time playing as a tribal vassal, so I was really not doing very well at all. I wasn’t really aware of the raiding mechanic so I was completely unable to accrue wealth for those early stages of the game. I conquered Ce (Aberdeenshire I guess?) but lost it to Gavelkind succession and then engaged in a horrific feud with my Doric cousins over the next few years. This culminated with the sack of Ueris (Forres) by the Chief of Ce, my sneaky harelipped cousin Rubert (who I’d actually tried to have installed as king by faction many years before, the ungrateful turd). During this sack Rubert captured my son and two of my daughters and forced one of them into concubinage which is basically the most harrowing thing that has ever happened to my family in the game. I was eventually able to ransom one son and a daughter back, but he kept my youngest daughter for decades. Naturally, I dedicated the next few years to getting back at him. Eventually, I bribed one of his bishops to put poison in his drink and he died like the Ramsay Bolton-esque dog he was. However, by that time my daughter had been away so long that much to my sadness, she actually preferred to stay in Ce. I believe she eventually married a courtier. I hope in the end she found some happiness. But this being Crusader Kings 2, I doubt it.

It was about this time that one of the more unusual characters in this playthrough emerged, and I’m still a little disappointed my attempt to name him my tanist (heir with Tanistry, kind of like elective succession but kept within the same family) and play him failed. Listen, if ye will, to the tale of Castantin the Conqueror. The early 9th Century saw Pictland hit by numerous Viking raids, and on one of these raids, Ueris was once again burned to the ground and prisoners were taken. Among them was a cousin of my character, Castantin, who was just a boy at the time. I spent ages saving up for a ransom, but by the time I had enough to pay for the child’s return, the damage was done. Castantin was now a Norse pagan, and embraced everything that went with it. I shrugged and put him out of my mind, and went on to expand my demesne by conquering Tyrconnell. I was pretty smug until I saw what Castantin had been doing while I was fighting the Irish.  Castantin had taken over Northumbria! And a great swath of land in central Ireland. And to top it off, he appeared to have been vassalised by the King of Bavaria? I like to think he offered his services to the King in exchange for land in the newly conquered territory and had gathered a party of his old Danish buddies to go and make their fortunes. And now he was the most powerful Duke in the British Isles, with six of the best counties including Dublin and York. What a guy. The upshot of this is that I never really got the chance to fight the Saxons after all, because by the time I had to fight border skirmishes to the south, all the Saxons were dead at the hands of Castantin’s Vikings and their Bavarian allies.

Eventually I gave up the tribal life, since it was doing nothing for me, and embraced feudalism. Shortly after, my spymaster (who had been blinded after being caught spying on Byzantine tech, in the first of a long line of indications the Byzantines are bad news) found out my liege was plotting to revoke my title, so I had him offed and then forced myself into the position of Duke in the power vacuum. Then it was mere moments before I was able to push another faction on the king, who ceded power to me to avoid civil war. So it came to pass that Caruorst Uerterio became the first Uerterio king of Pictland, and ushered the country out of its dark phase of barbarism and civil war. In doing so, I eliminated the last few embers of the emerging “Scottish” culture. Good pikemen or not, I was never going to relinquish my Pictish heritage, never!

Caruorst earned well his title of “The Great”. Possessed of martial skill, charm and a fine ginger beard, he quickly subjugated the warring counts of Ireland, and created a second kingdom. But he was not done yet. Taking up the Pope’s call to crusade in Iberia, Caruorst launched an attack on Galicia and quickly beat back the unprepared Moorish forces. So now I had three kingdoms. Caruorst may have been a fine warrior but he was something of a disaster in all other facets of life. His cousin and close friend Gigurum was his tanist, but he managed to sour that relationship by sleeping with and impregnating his wife. I felt bad for Gigurum, since this was his third wife and every one of them had cheated on him at least once. To make matters worse, Gigurum was Caruorst’s spymaster, so began constantly trying to kill him. Luckily, Caruorst perished in a battle against the Bavarians before the situation could truly come to a head.

Gigurum was kind of an underrated king. Despite his unpopularity with his vassals he continued mopping up the remaining Irish counties as well as some of the Bavarian lands in Northumbria. Then he triumphed in the crusade for Andalusia, bringing his number of kingdoms to four. The next few monarchs spent their time consolidating these gains, snapping up as much Muslim land in Spain as possible at the same time as picking up counties in Wales, eventually forming another Kingdom there.

His heir, Aniel “the Rash” (named for a bastard of the dynasty who proved one of the most unshakable generals during the crusade) proclaimed an empire and continued the partition of Spain. He made it his life’s work to conquer Bohemia, his mother’s country, and planned this while making gains in Mauretania. Aniel eventually launched an attack on Bohemia and was able to take it, but in doing so sowed the seeds of the empire’s later disintegration. With his vassals supporting another candidate for tanist other than his selected heir, Ganant, he destroyed the Kingdom title, giving himself a whole bunch of duke and earl level vassals he could never transfer away… more on that fateful decision later. Aniel also helped his nephew the King of Lombardy conquer Africa, although he would eventually lose it in a rebellion. Aniel also finally conquered the Greeks of England and the Bavarians of Northumbria to hold the entirety of the British Isles. Given that I already had an empire title, I decided not to claim the title of Emperor of Brittannia, because I know how difficult it is to maintain two empire titles on any kind of elective succession. After an unprecedented number of years on the throne, Aniel died of old age. An impetuous and ambitious leader, he truly earned his nickname.


Emperor Ganant married Butayna, the Queen of Africa, and decided to put an end to the constant African/Lombard rivalry. At some point I must have obtained Africa as a vassal kingdom but I still don’t remember how. Anyway, Ganant and Butayna launched an attack on Lombardy and took it in a pretty intense battle. With Butayna “the Great” now Queen of Africa and, hell let’s just call it Italy, she and Ganant went about solidifying their power over the Mediterranean basin. An opportunity to steal territory from the Franks occurred, when the Emperor of Francia idiotically created the Empire of Hispania. Of course, unable to secure the succession of his heir to both empires, Hispania broke away from Francia, taking with it much of its territory in Castille and Aragon as well as some duchies in France itself. Because (I think) the Empire of Hispania was in the de jure territory of the Empire of Pictland, and also because of the hilariously mingled family trees of medieval rulers, the heir to the Empire of Hispania was… some old guy. BUT, his heir was Ganant. Naturally, assassins were summoned. Unfortunately the old guy went into hiding, and he and Ganant had a furious race not to be the first to die so that Hispania would be absorbed into the empire (Ganant was getting on in years at this point). Then lo and behold, the old guy died! Ganant, clearly not learning from Aniel’s mistakes, immediately destroyed the Empire title and gave himself a whole bunch more vassals he could never transfer.

Then the Black Death rolled in! Mostly nobody in the realm cared at first because they were too busy dealing with the scandal of Ganant and Butayna’s son and daughter converting to Kharijite Islam. But eventually, yeah it turned out to be kind of a big deal. Queue a couple of years of hiding in the castle while the peasants perish and bodies piled up in the streets. The people went a little bit crazy, and were looking for someone to blame. Ganant suggested it was probably witchcraft, and inadvertently started a Satanic panic. Wild-eyed courtiers started bringing him suspected witches (probably just D&D loving teenagers) who I duly imprisoned. They started calling for them to be burned at the stake, but by this point Ganant figured it had gone on for too long. He released the accused witches and told everyone just to chill the hell out with their witchcraft shit. The courtiers relented, but this was far from over. Ganant returned to his chambers on night to find Butayna “the Great”, Empress of Pictland, Queen of Africa and Italy, murdered at the hands of the same zealots he had himself stirred up. Thus he earned his nickname: Ganant “The Careless”. Ganant lived for a few more years, but he was never the same again. He died a broken man, never forgiving himself for his mistakes.
Along the way somebody conquered Poland. I don’t remember who. Also Sweden. All I remember about this one was that a dwarf named Borkvard was involved somehow.

The next Emperor of note was Uuen “the Black”. A cynical and bitter man, Uuen had spent his early life focused on learning, given that his club foot precluded a traditional knightly education. On becoming emperor he moved quickly to consolidate power, assassinating a number of rivals, apparently unconcerned with whether or not they were members of his own family. He was definitely not the first Uerturio to be a kinslayer, but he was certainly the first to get caught. Later in life the Pope would grant him absolution for this sin, but in his early days he was hated and feared because of it. It was around this time that Uuen began to become irritated by some of his minor vassals, notably Bosun “the Evil” the Duke of Upper Burgundy, who constantly plotted against him and eventually raised his banners in rebellion, suffering a quite grisly fate. Wounded in numerous battles, Duke Bosun lost a hand and part of his face, before ending up in Uuen’s prison, where he died of cancer soon after. The next Duke, also Bosun, was not much better. Another vassal causing problems was Alboin of Barcelona, who had managed to hoover up an astonishing six duchies and was the instigator of most of the factions against Uuen.

Uuen married Zoe, Princess of the Byzantine Empire, having one child together, Uirup. But when Zoe fell pregnant with the child of a lewd duke, Uuen imprisoned her in a rage. Zoe would live in the prison for the rest of her life with her bastard daughter, a simple girl who died from disease aged twelve, leaving her mother alone. Uuen remarried with Èlodie, Princess of Francia and had a further three children.

Uuen did not do much in the way of conquering, though, due to the quite ridiculous defensive pacts formed against the Picts at this time. In any case, he was concerned with a new threat from the East. The Mongol Empire was expanding across Eurasia and the eastern Christian kingdoms were hard pressed to stop their advance, with the fractious Byzantines too concerned with their own power struggles to put up much of a defence. Uuen elected to aid the King of Mordvinia in his defence against the Mongols but was too late to stop the horsemen of the steppes from gobbling up half of the Russians’ territory. Meanwhile the King of Georgia broke free from the Byzantines, and presumably felt quite smug for a few moments there, before the northern part of his kingdom was absorbed by the hordes. With Pictish holdings in Bohemia and Poland directly threatened it looked like war was imminent.

But it was not in the east that the Mongols struck. When Georgia broke away, a small portion of Latium south of Rome had gone with it. Now, with a swathe of Georgian territory in the hands of the Mongols, one county with a port became property of the Khans. The Mongols aimed to expand that territory, and using their Italian holdings as a springboard, they wrested Rome away from the Franks who had held it since before the Pictish/African conquest. Uuen likely felt a little conflicted on this account. On one hand, hey, thanks for kicking the Franks out of Rome for us, but on the other… Rome in the hands of pagan barbarians is not good for Christendom in general and pagan barbarians in mainland Italy is definitely not something to be tolerated. Uuen “The Black” – atheist cynic, kinslayer and wife-imprisoner, would play the defender of Christendom. The Picts declared war, and mustered their armies. Now, by this point the Mongols 90,000 troop event-spawned doomstack had diminished somewhat, but they could still field a lot of troops, and had two 20,000 stacks active in Italy. I fielded an army of just over 40,000, including about 10,000 cavalry and heavy infantry retinues. In the Tuscan countryside a single, decisive battle was fought. Thanks to the generalship of Gede, Uuen’s best friend and marshal, the Mongols were turned back and sent packing, their manpower severely diminished. The Mongols are now no longer a threat, and the Khan has recently converted to Christianity. The Holy Father wrote to Uuen thanking him and requesting that he return Rome to the Fraticelli Papacy. Uuen’s response was something along the lines of “Sod you, we’re keeping it.”

Something changed in Uuen after this battle, though. He had always had an interest in the religions and history of India, and I think he may have felt kinship with the ancient Indian Emperor Chandragupta Maurya, who had a life-changing experience after personally witnessing the human cost of his own conquests. Like Chandragupta Maurya, he converted to Jainism (although in secret because, yeah, medieval Europe is not the most tolerant of places). Entering a Jain secret society, he realised that basically everyone has been secretly practising Jainism for years. His mother, his wife, his good buddy Gede. Everyone! Uuen and Gede started discussing a plan to eventually convert the Empire to Jainism. Buuuuuut then he died of food poisoning. I suspect that Uuen wasn’t taking the whole vegetarian thing seriously. Well, beats starving yourself to death in a cave, I guess.
Emperor Gede dealt with some more internal squabbles, particularly from the awful Dukes of Barcelona and Upper Burgundy, who were a huge in pain in the ass as usual. To top it off, Gede was monumentally depressed when his friend Uuen died. Now, Gede was peace-loving secret Jain as well but he hadn’t quite ditched the warlike streak like his old friend. Thus, it didn’t take too much for his friend’s son Uirup to convince him to push his claim on the 9-year-old Byzantine Empress, who was in the middle of a rebellion. Mustering his troops into five 10,000 man doomstacks, they sieged their way through Dalmatia, conquering province after province, facing little resistance from the overwhelmed child Empress. Although Gede died of old age before the war could be completed, Uirup was now Emperor of both Pictland and Byzantium. And from this point on the game was essentially unwinnable.

A word about Uirup. Uirup is the WORST.

Uuen never wanted this for Uirup. He packed him off as soon as he came of age to marry a disfigured duchess in England where he would never have anything asked of him and would never do any harm. Oh boy, was this not what happened. Somehow, all my vassals voted for Uirup as Gede’s successor, apparently because they were getting all nostalgic for Uuen’s time in the hot seat. Don’t worry, it didn’t last long. Uirup has a diplomacy score of zero and a stewardship score that isn’t much better. Given that he’s also a foreign conqueror to half of his subjects, he’s having a little trouble.
The main problem is revenue. I’m bringing in less than nine gold on a good month. The Empire is now hilariously overstretched. I don’t have Imperial Administration because I didn’t realise you had to have been changing laws to favour the ruler all along. My attitude to things like banishment or war committees is kind of “sure, let them vote on it” so I never felt I needed to change them. As a result of this, as well as Aniel and Ganant’s reckless destruction of titles, I have 52 vassals and only a 29 vassal limit. Getting Imperial Administration at this point is impossible, mainly because none of my council will support the law changes I propose. Neither will they let me buy favours, they hate Uirup that much they literally won’t take a bribe from him. I’ve already given away all the vassals I could, and created all the kingdom titles I could – Sicily, Croatia, Greece, Armenia, Anatolia, Mesopotamia, maybe a couple of others – and I could still only get it down to about 32, only for it to fly back up again when I inevitably had to fight three or four successive rebellions and revoke the titles from the offenders.

That’s the other thing. I’m facing continual factions and revolts. Even vassals that love me because I just made them kings are plotting against me. I’m currently fighting off some Avarian duke who’s pushing a courtier’s claim on the Byzantine Empire with only my 10K retinues and about 5K extra men while at the same time fighting the King of Croatia who’s rebelling because I tried to have him arrested. And since I’m bankrupt from fighting the last few wars with mercs, those retinues aren’t going to be reinforced any time soon.

To top things off: I am going to lose the Byzantine Empire. I managed to switch it to tanistry, so that my heir Domelch (Half-brother, Uuen and Èlodie’s kid) would inherit both. And this worked for a while, before the electors in Byzantium very deliberately switched their loyalties to Amalrich “the Just” the goodie-two-shoes Earl of Hamburg, from a cadet branch of the Uerturio family. I have virtually no plot power so killing him is out of the question. Except for using the console to kill him, I don’t see any way to avoid the fact that not only am I going to lose Byzantium to Amalrich, he’s also going to take his lands in Germany with him, as well as Mauretania and Andalusia because he’s just been elected heir to those too. So to sum up, I am losing not only the Empire I conspired and fought so hard to get (all right I beat a 9-year-old but you get the point) I am also losing two entire Kingdoms – including my capital, Seville – and a bunch of miscellaneous territory in Francia. And probably Alexandria since I gave it to the King of Sicily… aaaaaaagggghhhhh.

That’s why I say: This is it. This is the high water mark. It’s never going to get any better than this. This is the beginning of my empire’s downfall. Trajan was definitely a better Emperor than Uirup, but I doubt he had the same perspective. To think I harboured dreams of reforming the Roman Empire itself! To think I planned to push Domelch’s claim on Francia and take that too! Hubris! Hubris I say!
I understand why this is happening. To be honest, the game doesn’t WANT you to be able to take this much territory. Blobbing is fine, up until a point, and then no more. It’s not really realistic for me to be able to take over the entirety of Europe. But I wanted to be able to push this as far as I could, and build the ultimate Pictland to transfer over to EUIV.

Now I’m not sure what to do. Do I try and steer the Empire through its downward spiral? Settle for being second best to reinvigorated Byzantium (third best if you include the now untouchable Francia, I suppose). Or, the second option… I cheat. I’ll kill Amalrich using a console command, give myself a buttload of cash and weather the inevitable rebellions. Third option, I go back to before I declared war on Byzantium, and just don’t do it. Find some other way to expand my glorious Pictish Empire.
Or… transfer Byzantium to my primary title and destroy the Empire of Pictland… thereby making Amalrich my heir, solving a lot of my vassal problems in the process. Move my capital to Constantinople as I would have already if there wasn’t so much heat in that vicinity. So what will it be? Double down on the mistake or try to erase it? Perhaps there’s a chance after all. Perhaps, if I keep persevering, I can stop the terrible decline… be Trajan, forever expanding. We’ll see.